Pacific Northwest Research Station

Title: Structuring expert input for a knowledge-based approach to watershed condition assessment for the Northwest Forest Plan, USA

Author: Gordon, Sean N.; Kirsten, Gallo.

Date: 2011

Source: Environmental Monitoring Assessment. 172(1-4): 643-661

Description: Assessments of watershed condition for aquatic and riparian species often have to rely on expert opinion because of the complexity of establishing statistical relationships among the many factors involved. Such expert-based assessments can be difficult to document and apply consistently over time and space. We describe and reflect on the process of developing a computer based decision support application from expert judgments for assessing aquatic and riparian conditions over the 100,000 km² managed by the US federal government under the Northwest Forest Plan. The decision support system helped structure and document the assessment process and provided consistency and transparency to the evaluation methodology. However, many decisions and trade-offs were required in the expert engagement and model-building processes. Knowledge elicitation in an interactive group had a number of benefits over nominal group or Delphi processes, but efficient knowledge capture required considerable planning and expertise in the subject matter and modeling process. Communicating model results for validation was problematic and only effectively accomplished via in-person workshops. The choice to use different expert groups for each biophysical province provided more opportunities for participation and promoted greater ownership in the assessment, but it also led to increased variation among the resulting model structures. We propose three possible approaches for better managing the consistency of assessment models when multiple expert groups are involved.

Keywords: watershed assessment, composite indicators, expert judgment, fuzzy logic, modeling, stream condition assessment, stream habitat

View and Print this Publication (2.08 MB)

Publication Notes: 

• We recommend that you also print this page and attach it to the printout of the article, to retain the full citation information.
• This article was written and prepared by U.S. Government employees on official time, and is therefore in the public domain.
• You may send email to pnw_pnwpubs@fs.fed.us to request a hard copy of this publication. (Please specify exactly which publication you are requesting and your mailing address.)

 Get the latest version of the Adobe Acrobat reader or Acrobat Reader for Windows with Search and Accessibility

Citation

Gordon, Sean N.; Kirsten, Gallo.  2011.  Structuring expert input for a knowledge-based approach to watershed condition assessment for the Northwest Forest Plan, USA.   Environmental Monitoring Assessment. 172(1-4): 643-661.